Siirry sisältöön

Sustainable promotion of fisheries – Effectiveness of fisheries fees and government grants to fisheries

The audited financial instruments for fisheries have produced individual results, some of which have even been significant. However, no comprehensive information on the effectiveness of the funding is available, as the monitoring of impacts have been limited, and the impacts often only become evident over a longer term.

Photo: Marko Kangas, Economic Development Centre of Lapland

Scope of the audit

  • Fisheries fees, restoration, development and trial projects relating to fisheries, NOUSU migratory fish programme, the European Maritime and Fisheries Fund (EMFF 2014–2020) and the European Maritime, Fisheries and Aquaculture Fund (EMFAF 2021–2027)
  • Effectiveness of government grants and use of funds
  • Appropriateness of funding and other policy instruments for sustainable promotion of fisheries as a whole.

Key findings

  • The steering impact of fisheries strategies on funding is partly unclear.
  • Monitoring, reporting, evaluation and communication of the funding have produced little information on effectiveness.
  • While some of the strategic goals have been achieved, no comprehensive information is available on the effectiveness of the funding.
  • The fragmentation of the funding increases the administrative workload and undermines effectiveness.
  • Restrictions associated with the Water Act and conflicts between fisheries and other interests hamper the sustainable promotion of fisheries.

Briefly

The purpose of the audit was to produce information for updates of national fisheries strategies and evaluation of funding packages. In recent years, the total amount allocated to the audited fisheries funding instruments in central government budgets has varied between approx. EUR 23 and 31 million annually. Funding has been allocated to thousands of different projects or measures, most of which are very small.

The purpose of the Fishing Act is to secure a sustainable and diversified return on fish resources, the natural life cycle of fish stocks, and the diversity and protection of fish resources and other aquatic flora and fauna. Such funding as the fisheries fees have, however, been mainly used for fish stocking projects that have compensated for damage caused to fishing but done little to address harms to the fish stocks.

The process to amend the fisheries regulations applicable to hydropower plants in the Rivers Kemijoki and Raudanjoki began in 2017, and it is likely that the dispute will go through all instances of administrative courts.

Fisheries restoration projects supported by state funds have often been sporadic and fragmented, which erodes their effectiveness and sustainability. NOUSU migratory fish programme has produced promising outcomes, especially in projects in which barriers to fish migration have been removed completely, or circumvented using nature-like fishways.

While the ambitious fisheries growth targets set for the EMFF and EMFAF programmes have not been fully achieved, significant progress has been made in several areas. However, a large share of grants for fishing, in particular, has been fragmented and spent on very small procurements and compensation amounts, and little or no information is available on their effectiveness.

In quantitative terms, by far the largest share of individual fisheries fees (7,968, 40.6%) were less than or equal to EUR 500.
Breakdown of the number of individual fisheries fees (number;%) by amount category of the fee. Source: KAVERI information system data (N=19,646), compiled by the NAOF.
The highest number of projects by far, or 2,199 projects in total, were in the category of 1,000 to 5,000 euros.
Breakdown of the number of sustainable fisheries projects paid for (EMFF) and granted (EMFF) by the amount category of the grant (incl. actions under the specific objectives of data collection and supervision of the EMFF programme). Source: Hyrrä information system and EMFF Programme Implementation Report, compiled by the NAOF.
Essential content of the figure is described in the body text.
Breakdown of project numbers in EMFF and EMFAF programmes (number;%) by content. Source: Hyrrä information system and EMFF Programme Implementation Report, compiled by the NAOF.

Recommendations of the National Audit Office

The Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry should, in cooperation with the Ministry of Finance and the Ministry of the Environment if necessary, clarify the fisheries funding strategy, for example in the context of the ongoing and forthcoming updates of strategic plans and programmes concerning fisheries and as the national partnership plan for the new EU funding period 2028–2034 is drawn up. The aim should be at creating broader funding packages that are more cost-effective and reduce the administrative workload and, where possible, at using new result-based funding models. At the same time, it would be possible to clarify and strengthen coordination between financial instruments and administrative branches, prioritisation of fisheries authorities' duties, as well as the monitoring, reporting, evaluation and communication of the effectiveness of funding and information management as a whole.

When fisheries strategies and funding programmes are updated, the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry should promote an approach based on effectiveness in which the targets, indicators for their achievement, baseline data, target levels, funding criteria and monitoring as well as reporting and evaluation procedures make up a clear, comprehensive and consistent entity. The effectiveness-based approach should also be extended to the project management of government grants and its guidelines.

The Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry should, together with the Finnish Food Authority and the Employment, Development and Administration Centre (KEHA Centre), develop the information systems for administrating fisheries funding to enable and facilitate monitoring, reporting, evaluation and communication of the effectiveness of funding.

The Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry should periodically commission reviews of the effectiveness of all government grant programmes for fisheries as provided in section 36 of the Act on Discretionary Government Grants. In these reviews, versatile use should be made of evaluation designs and methods suitable for the situation in question, including statistical methods. The ministry should define clear procedures for processing and using review findings and recommendations as well as for decision-making and follow-up related to them.

In cooperation between the Ministry of Justice, the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry and other relevant ministries and stakeholders, the Water Act reform should be continued, systematically assessing the need and options for enhancing the effectiveness of fisheries obligations.

The Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry and other relevant ministries should develop and promote the use of procedures for systematic and professional mediation to resolve conflicts related to fisheries, hydropower, nature conservation and water management interests.

Timing of follow-up

The follow-up of the audit will be conducted in 2028.

Contact person

Nina von Hertzen-Oosi

Principal Performance Auditor

Performance audit

Audit areas: Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry, Ministry of Education and Culture, Ministry of the Environment